From the IAmAnAtheist feedback form:
I Love what you did here. Its smart and funny. Here’s some thing I’ve been thinking about: christian: god loves eryone. He made everyone they way they are for a reason. and we should treat everyone equaly. Atheist: realy? then why do you tell gay people they will goto hell? Why does your bible favore men over woman?
christian: everyone has the right to belive what they want to belive in. atheist: then why did your people burn down villages and hang innocent people for not being christian?
Thanks for the nice comments!
About your suggested arguments — these are fun, but I’m not sure how many argument-prone Christians would say that we should treat everyone equally or that everyone has the right to believe what they want to believe.